One Nation’s migration plan: Deep harms and minimal benefits

Sayan
By Sayan
7 Min Read
Disclosure: This website may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. I only recommend products or services that I personally use and believe will add value to my readers. Your support is appreciated!


After months of public debate about Australia’s overall migration levels, One Nation has recaptured media attention with new proposals on humanitarian and family visas. They are part of a depressing tradition: deliberately inflammatory public debate about different categories that in reality make up a tiny share of migration to Australia.

The plan One Nation released in September was focused on large-scale cuts to temporary migration. Pauline Hanson’s new announcement turns the focus to permanent migration, proposing to abolish the permanent parent visa category, slash the refugee resettlement program by 90%, and abolish the onshore asylum program.

These proposals would have deep harms, and the claimed benefits are, in context, minimal.

Related Article Block Placeholder

Article ID: 1272161

Parent and refugee categories are not a significant part of Australia’s migration intake. Cutting them would have negligible impacts on the housing and infrastructure pressures that One Nation claims to focus on. The party’s “net-negative” plan requires cuts to net migration of something like 300,000 per year; less than 10% of that would be achieved by this new announcement.

It is true that humanitarian and parent migration are relatively costly categories for the government. On average, these migrants will benefit more from government spending than they will pay in taxes over their lifetime (as does the average Australian). But these costs, not especially significant in context, are more than offset by the large positive budget impacts of other permanent and temporary migration categories.

The main drivers of budget costs are health, aged care and the pension. Seven or eight thousand parent migrants each year are a drop in the bucket compared to the 2.7 million (and rising) other Australians on the age pension. And the claimed saving of $14 billion a year is across all expenditure at all levels of government, which means it has to be understand relative to the more than $1.1 trillion that Commonwealth and state governments spend each year.

Ultimately, though, the purpose of One Nation’s announcement is less about specific budget savings and more about provoking an argument over the more compassionate parts of our migration system.

The refugee resettlement program, for example, is something Australians should be proud of. Resettlement is life-changing, bringing refugees directly from their regions of origin and giving them a chance to start again. It most closely resembles the mythical process of patiently “waiting in the queue” that anti-refugee politicians say they want. Australia is, as Hanson says, a world leader in this area, alongside Canada. Even for John Howard, this was a point of pride, not something that we should whittle down to match the shamefully minimal efforts of other OECD countries, as One Nation proposes.

The onshore asylum system, too, is an important mechanism for protecting vulnerable people, though it has been beset by mismanagement and attempted fraud since the Dutton years. One Nation’s proposal to eliminate it is flatly incompatible with international refugee law. It would also be an administrative nightmare, since it’s proposed to keep a ministerial discretion for exceptional cases — a far more complex, paperwork-heavy way to handle what would inevitably become thousands of cases.

The restatement of One Nation’s proposed visa ban for some “unsafe” countries underlines how these changes are designed to provoke, not tackle, any substantive problem. Visa applicants, especially resettled refugees, are already screened extensively. Using the Smartraveller “do not travel” list as the basis for this policy is a thin veneer of respectability over an obvious attempt to replicate the Trump “Muslim ban”.

Related Article Block Placeholder

Article ID: 1273010

The proposals for parent visas, however, are a slightly different story. They are not going to fix the budget or the housing crisis. But this is a genuinely broken part of the migration system. Demand for parent visas is far higher than the number the government is willing to grant, due to the budget impacts. As a result, the wait time is in the decades and getting longer, and a parent visa application is more an exercise in far-future speculation than a concrete migration pathway.

There are no great solutions to this. But ending permanent parent migration and retaining visas for long-term visits is a real option, canvassed in the government’s 2023 Review of the Migration System, which at least has the virtue of being honest about the fact that governments are not willing to support parent migration at anywhere close to the scale of demand.

The major parties know this: the Coalition introduced a longer-stay temporary visa for parents, and Labor commissioned the 2023 review. But they would prefer not to think about it, since no policy change in this area will make anyone particularly happy. One Nation staking out this ground, with provocative rhetoric about budget costs instead of a focus on the families caught up in the dysfunctional existing system, just further guarantees that the government won’t go near it.

One Nation’s plans for the migration system are still full of holes. We do not know how many permanent skilled and partner visas they plan to grant or what level of overseas migration they are targeting for the radical first three years of their plan. Their net-negative proposal implies major reductions in temporary skilled migration, but the party has not specifically said it intends to do that, or how. Instead of filling in these gaps, Hanson is taking her usual route — loud new announcements that blow small issues out of proportion in order to retain her status as Australian politics’ provocateur-in-chief.



Source link

Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *