Pauline Hanson, Ipswich and the politics of memory

Sayan
By Sayan
16 Min Read
Disclosure: This website may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. I only recommend products or services that I personally use and believe will add value to my readers. Your support is appreciated!


You can leave your hometown, but you will never escape it. I sometimes feel as though Ipswich has followed me across oceans and decades, and I wonder why, because all it has to do is wait a while and I’ll be back. I was back for winter this year, flying up the freeway past the haunted insane asylum on the far side of the train tracks, letting the car do most of the driving, wondering if anybody still cut laps in town, and how many laps I’d have to cut in an electric Volvo before somebody picked a fight.

Three laps, I reckon.

Three circuits of Limestone Street, up past the op shop and McDonald’s, a hairpin right around the bottle-o at the Federal, where I tried to order, “Six tins of beer, thank you,” the first time I ever tried to order any drink, down Brisbane Street past Vogels Sports Store, where I got my first real cricket bat and…

No, wait.

Vogels was Voglers, and they were a gunsmith and a hobby shop, not a sports store. You could buy umbrellas there too, I think. Good ones, made by hand. Or maybe it was Goleby’s? Maybe that was the sports store everyone went to for their first bat, their first set of pads — or your netball gear if you were a girl. Because back then the girls played netball and the blokes played cricket in the summer and footy through winter, and there was none of this confusing carry-on about…

No.

Bugger it. Wrong again.

Related Article Block Placeholder

Article ID: 1272325

Goleby’s was a saddler and harness-maker on the corner of Brisbane and West streets. He had a life-size statue of a horse in the shop, not racks of Gray-Nicolls scoops and Slazenger bats with Don Bradman’s signature.

So, who ran the sports store?

It was lucky, I guess, that the car was doing the driving, because I clearly wasn’t. I was sitting at precisely 100 kilometres an hour on a bright, cool day in July, the EX30 handling lane-keeping and safe distance, the silicon unconscious but the ride utterly flawless, while I was somewhere else, lost in a half-forgotten, misremembered Ipswich, more real to me than the high-speed river of steel through which I was flying. A bright orange Cortina, beautifully preserved, growling like a tiger tank, cut in on me just outside Redbank, not far from where an old schoolmate, with a whole carton of Foster’s under his belt, drove the wrong way up an off-ramp that isn’t there anymore.

Neither is my old mate.

The Volvo braked hard, pulling me back into the real. Memory is treacherous. You give it a chance and it’ll mess you up. At speed, it might even kill you.

Mostly, though, for that morning at least, it was content to mess with me.

Having driven deep into my personal history, on a first tentative expedition to probe the roots of One Nation’s increasingly popular blood and soil nativism, I was to find my map of the past had been drawn with great confidence and no particular accuracy. Not because things had changed. That’s what things do. But because my memory of them, long assumed to form the bedrock of a personal origin story, instead revealed all such memories to be shifting, treacherous sediment.

Of course, for Pauline Hanson and the far right, politics is all about memory, all the time. They are aggrieved nostalgics. Press them, and they will swear to imagining a bright future for Australia, but press harder, and that future starts to feel like a damp, grey Tuesday in 1953, with a Holden FJ in every driveway and no foreign silliness on the wireless at 6 pm, when the pubs all shut.

She’s consistent, I suppose. For thirty years she’s been beating against the current of modernity, ceaselessly trying to drag us back into the past, before we “lost all our big Australian industries and icons,” back when “Arthur Calwell was a great Australian,” when she was taught to salute the flag at school and all Australians “were taught values, morals, honesty, work ethic and common sense — things very much lacking today”. Sometimes she stretches memory all the way back before Federation, when “Australia had a national identity” and “it had nothing to do with diversity”. Sometimes there is no fixed date, just a longing for a time when wages rose, and jobs were plentiful, and migrants looked like us, a time before “Ford and Holden closed their factories”.

Related Article Block Placeholder

Article ID: 1272161

On the face of it, there’s nothing remarkable about a conservative conjuring dreams of a better past. Conservatism, by definition, is rooted in the known certainties of what went before, and, as a practical matter, nostalgia is a powerful, emotionally resonant shortcut for mobilising voters who feel threatened by rapid social, economic or cultural change — what Redbridge’s Alex Fein calls “hostile complexity”.

“Because everything is so messy in the information sphere. It’s impossible to know what’s true there,” she said, as I was about a quarter-hour out from Phil’s place. She wasn’t in the car with me, just her voice on a podcast. “Government services and eligibility and things like that are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate. Privatised systems are also incredibly difficult to navigate. You don’t know when you’re getting scammed. And so scams become indistinguishable from legitimate government programs or legitimate businesses.”

What she meant was we live in an accelerated, deeply uncertain timeline, an era of epistemic collapse, and normal people, not sickos like me binging politics podcasts at 100 km/h on the freeway up to Ipswich, are overwhelmed.

“And in there comes someone like Hanson,” said Fein, “with a really simple and clear message that’s about agency: that she can be the conduit by which they regain agency over their lives.”

“You’re not wrong, mate,” I muttered to myself, or maybe to her, because of the weird parasocial connection we all fall victim to after enough exposure to anyone’s online thoughts.

Alone in my car, debating with Fein, speeding up the freeway towards my oldest friend in the world, I thought Hanson was both a little more complicated than that, and her message in many ways much simpler, an old folktale about who are friends, who are enemies and what must be done to protect hearth and home. Because the inverse of Hanson’s signal on belonging is a thirty-year effort, relentless and ugly, to define out of the Australian story those who don’t belong.

Infamously, that meant the very first Australians, when she exploded into public prominence with a sustained attack on the “Aboriginal industry”. Shortly after that, and just a few minutes into her maiden speech to parliament in 1996, after complaining about the outrageous privileges extended to Aborigines over white Australians, she switched fire to a new target: “We are in danger of being swamped by Asians.”

She soon moved on to Muslims, and while that particular jihad remains her very own forever war, she’s most recently opened up a new fight against “the transgender insurgency”. For Hanson, there must always be an Other on which to focus our fear and loathing, an enemy against whom forces might be marshalled and, more importantly, led.

Again, there’s nothing unusual or remarkable about this. John Howard beat Kim Beazley with it. But as I drew closer to Ipswich, peeling off the freeway at Riverview — I can assure you there is no view of the river — and slowing down at the edge of town, coming up on the Bunnings they built over the old skate rink, I wondered if Hanson even understood her new appeal.

Related Article Block Placeholder

Article ID: 1271349

Fein seemed to.

“A lot of the people who are considering One Nation for the first time, they might have concerns around crime that then get conflated with migration, but that’s not really the thing that’s driven them into the arms of One Nation,” she told Mark Kenny and Dr Marija Taflaga on their Democracy Sausage podcast, as I pulled off the main road at the Racehorse Hotel. “There is a real sense of having been failed by the political class … They can’t really imagine a situation that would be worse than the situation they’re in right now. The pressures are just so enormous on them. And so they will, they will say literally … how could it get any worse than it already is? May as well try something new.”

But Pauline Hanson is not offering something new.

Like Nigel Farage in the UK, or the AfD in Germany, like Le Pen in France, and of course like Trump when he was still cognitively capable of making a semi-coherent case, she offers to fold time back on itself, to unmake the new and return us to the once upon a time, to the Kingdom of Again, where we can be safe again, and prosperous again, and one united people forever again.

There is a useful way of thinking about this in the work of the historian Simon Schama, who argued in Landscape and Memory that we do not first encounter a landscape as an objective thing and then attach meaning to it. We encounter it already saturated with memory, myth and association. Hanson performs something similar with the past itself. She constructs not so much a historical period as a landscape of the mind, a remembered Australia whose emotional contours are familiar even when its geography and chronology are impossible to pin down.

If you feel a measure of uncertainty around the particulars of exactly when and where you might find this realm, that is because the entire concept is hidden inside a quantum box. The precise when of our better past is something to be accepted but not known, because to open the box and stare directly at a revealed truth collapses everything into confronting complexity. Are we going back to the earliest days of Federation, say, when bubonic plague burned through Sydney, or the golden-tinted post-war years, when Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander women were forcibly sterilised?

It almost doesn’t matter. The memory need not survive contact with the archive, because what Hanson is offering is not really a history lesson. It is an interpretation of memory itself, a way of gathering scattered recollections of security, prosperity, belonging and social harmony and arranging them into a single, imagined past. The memories can be partial, selective, contradictory, even false, and still perform their political function. They don’t have to establish that the golden age existed. They only have to make people feel as if they remember it.

There can never be an exact moment to which we can return because any moment held up as an ideal to which we might return immediately presents its own negation. Because of this, in Hanson’s three major set-piece speeches — her maiden address to parliament in 1996, her maiden speech to the Senate in 2016, and this year’s first-ever address to the Press Club — it can and has ranged from back in colonial times all the way up until 2006: the last time, according to her, that Australia was debt-free. (Spoiler: it was not.)

Related Article Block Placeholder

Article ID: 1271322

“There’s just this general kind of sense that we used to be a society that you could understand,” Mark Kenny explained as I turned onto Glebe Road, where I’d done most of my growing up. People had values, he said, but they also felt that they themselves had individual value. “And now all of that’s gone.”

I turned off the pod to enjoy the familiar drive. It was always surprising how little and how much changed. This was where I’d gone to primary school, played cricket at Cameron Park and wandered as freely as any child of the 1970s could, walking uphill both ways in the baking heat of summer to visit Phil at his place down in Booval. To borrow from Schama, it was not just something to look at; it was already saturated with memory, myth, culture and meaning.

Also, the car smelled of cheese.

This is an edited extract of John Birmingham’s Quarterly Essay Another Country: The Rise and Rise of One Nation, available now.



Source link

Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *