As early as September 2015, historian and journalist Rick Perlstein mused on the relevance of the “F-word” — fascism — in relation to the violent rhetoric at rallies staged by the then Republican candidate Donald Trump, who even back then was hinting at his distrust of unfavourable election results.
Once Trump became president, the word followed, with his first term generating a stream of books like Timothy Snyder’s On Tyranny (2017), Jason Stanley’s How Fascism Works (2018) and Madeleine Albright’s Fascism: A Warning (2018). Significantly, Robert Paxton, the world’s leading scholar of the far right, joined the chorus after Trump backed MAGA supporters who invaded the Capitol building after the 2020 election. “I’ve hesitated to call Donald Trump a fascist,” Paxton wrote in Newsweek. “Until now.”
When Trump returned to office in 2025, he pardoned or commuted the sentences of 1,500 people involved in the “Stop the Steal” riots (including leaders of white supremacist groups like the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers). He repeatedly deployed troops to quell protests in US cities, while allowing ICE agents to wear masks and drive unmarked cars as they raided immigrant communities. At various times he even mused about sending the National Guard or ICE to the polling booths.
Many people were thus worried about the midterm elections. On November 1, The Guardian warned its readers about Trump’s “brazen effort to interfere with voting in this year’s midterm elections”. The US president had, after all, repeatedly suggested the process could not be trusted, and refused to rule out declaring a state of emergency, something many MAGA activists were calling for.
But the elections proceeded without disruption, and Trump even accepted the results (though he has quickly returned to casting doubt on their legitimacy). These points specifically reflect a significant difference between Trumpism and the fascists of the 1930s, whose determination to quell democracy manifested in the paramilitary forces with which they annihilated their opponents.
Despite occasional overtures to far-right thugs (such as his reference to “very fine people on both sides” after the Charlottesville rallies in 2017), Trump hasn’t forged his own street-fighting movement (even if he’s sometimes treated ICE as a private militia). Nor, for that matter, has he built his own independent party standing in opposition to mainstream politics. The Italian fascists and the German National Socialists organised outside a political establishment they despised; Trump, however, emerged within a traditional party of governance.
The GOP had long been a tent big enough to unite, say, Christian moralists worried about school prayer with fiscal conservatives opposed to government spending. Where old-school fascists styled themselves as “revolutionaries”, Trump merely expanded the Republican coalition further: dog-whistling to racists about Barack Obama’s citizenship, courting internet trolls through publications like Breitbart, and more generally employing his skills as a reality show personality to reach voters alienated from (and even hostile to) the political mainstream.
Initially, many conservatives were as appalled as liberals at how low Trump would stoop.

“Trump is a fascist,” tweeted author Max Boot in November 2015 when Trump proposed registering American Muslims in a special database. “And that’s not a term I use loosely or often. But he’s earned it.” At the time, Boot was working as an advisor to Marco Rubio; today Rubio serves as Trump’s secretary of state.
Similarly, in 2016, Robert Kennedy Jr — now health secretary — called Trump a “carnival barker” and suggested the main difference between him and Hitler was that “Hitler was interested in policy”. Meanwhile, J.D. Vance — now vice president — explained that he oscillated between thinking that Trump was “a cynical asshole like Nixon … or that he’s America’s Hitler”.
The electoral success of Trumpism induced ambitious conservatives to bend their knees. Yet the GOP remained a coalition, with white nationalists and other former fringe dwellers courted by Trump jostling with traditional right-wingers. Not surprisingly, Trump’s administration distinguished itself not by Nazi efficiency so much as policy paralysis, as Corey Robin notes.
Before the 2024 election, the Heritage Foundation, a right-wing think tank that has drawn up policy wish lists for Republican administrations going back to the Reagan era, sought to prepare both policies and personnel to give Trump’s second term more coherence. But its success has been limited precisely because Trump is less an ideologue than an opportunist: ill-disciplined and prone to sudden whims.
Rather than comparing Trump to Hitler, we might draw an analogy with Hungary’s gangsterish former prime minister Viktor Orbán, who, during 16 continuous years in office, deeply degraded his nation’s democratic traditions but who nevertheless still had to step down after a crushing electoral defeat earlier this year.
In the US, mass demonstrations against ICE in Minnesota showed the limits of Trump’s power. Unable to crush the protesters, the president retreated. By the time of the midterms, he seemed curiously disengaged from politics, more focused on redecorating Washington than the Republicans’ electoral prospects. Now the MAGA coalition is showing signs of fragmentation, with J.D. Vance, Ted Cruz and Florida Governor Ron DeSantis all distancing themselves from the president’s agenda.
Trump himself, temperamentally incapable of acknowledging defeat, has now begun claiming the midterms were rigged. As more traditional Republicans keep him at arm’s length, Trump has replaced chief of staff Susie Wiles, who once worked for Ronald Reagan, with Stephen Miller, the architect of the ICE-led mass deportation campaign.
Miller, whom alt-right leader Richard Spencer claims he mentored, is a genuine white nationalist: quite probably the most extreme figure in the administration. His ascension suggests that Trump, like an old showman facing a hostile crowd, will replay the hits of yesteryear, seeking to re-galvanise the MAGA base with renewed anti-immigration racism.
Almost certainly, there’s plenty of nastiness ahead. Still, Trump may find that times have changed.
In the past, he almost courted allegations of fascism, revelling in the liberal portrayal of him as a strongman. That’s why the midterms mattered. They pulled back the curtain to reveal the Great and Powerful Wizard of Trumpism as a weary octogenarian muttering about the algae in his reflecting pool.
Whether MAGA can recover from that remains to be seen.