
Nine’s cancelled review
The Nine papers have cancelled a book review of R.F. Kuang’s Taipei Story after the critic pushed back on an edit relating to a passage depicting a piano recital given by an Israeli musician. This passage has already seen controversy online, with some on social media criticising the passage for not referencing Gaza. This backlash has itself received backlash.
In Flynn Benson’s review, he says he had sought to add nuance, agreeing that the “mere representation of an Israeli character” does not indicate “Kuang’s complicity in genocide”, but that it was indeed odd “a 19-year-old Yale student … wouldn’t see an Israeli performer in 2025 and think of Gaza”.